Inspired by phutrick's Reasonable Cube, this is an attempt to foster a powerful, but largely fair draft environment full of interesting and diverse strategies. Fast mana such as Grim Monolith and Chrome Mox are absent as are the overly fast cheaty cards such as Show and Tell, Reanimate, and Natural Order. The purpose of this is not to discourage combo players, but to decrease the number of non-games and facilitate more involved, back-and-forth gameplay. Combo fiends are invited to indulge in some of the high-power/high-synergy build-around cards in the cube.
Major archetypes or themes:Blue control decks embody inevitability. Their top-end features such haymakers as Grave Titan and Shark Typhoon, so if the game goes on long enough, they'll win. Which means the entire purpose of the rest of the deck is to make sure the game goes long. Snatch spells off the stack with Mana Drain and Mana Leak, peal apart hands with Thoughtseize and scour the battlefield of opposing creatures with Go for the Throat, Path to Exile, and Abrade. Things getting a little too hairy? Beefy spells like Cryptic Command and Wrath of God have you covered. Survive long enough to thrive.
Don't like math? Big numbers scare you? Draft angry little dorks! Math is for blockers and big numbers don't stay big for long when you're swinging in with Ragavan, Nimble Pilferer and Robber of the Rich backed up by a fistful of Lightning Bolts and Fireblasts. Or maybe you'd prefer Champion of the Parish and Seasoned Hallowblade buffed by Thalia's Lieutenant? Oh, or how about endless Bloodsoaked Champion and Skyclave Shade strapped with Bonesplitter and Grafted Wargear? Efficient, streamlined, and ruthless; these are the decks that shark-people in business suits relate to on a spiritual level.
Midrange is an archetype that spans most colors and defines itself largely by its ability to shift-gears based on the situation. Fighting a big, mean control deck? Get lower to the ground and eat all their card advantage with Duress then cave their face in with Gideon, Ally of Zendikar. Staving off the bloodthirsty advances of aggro? Bulk up and pick off their little dorks with Incinerate before taking over the battlefield with Thragtusk. Or just ramp Birds of Paradise into Goblin Rabblemaster into Arc Trail + Infernal Grasp. Midrange decks are full of flexible and powerful cards that let it switch roles on the fly and handle whatever the opponent has on tap.
Without true turbo-ramp support, Green often functions as a midrange deck that's looking to win the inevitability battle against all but the durdly-est control decks by just being BIGGER. Most decks can answer a Questing Beast, but what about the follow-up Biogenic Ooze? Or the third? How about a Stonecoil Serpent where X is 6? Unlike turbo-ramp, you're not counting on getting to 6, 7, or 8 mana to start playing the game, but nobody else uses huge amounts of mana quite like green does.
Because so many of your cards are so individually powerful, these decks make great use of card selection and card advantage alike. Green brings a variety of selection effects such as Green Sun's Zenith, Abundant Harvest, Once Upon a Time, and Survival of the Fittest. Blue's cantrips and raw card advantage can take the deck over the top. Splashing red, white, or black brings more crossover with midrange decks, but, ya know, BIGGER.
Artifacts have spread their greedy little tendrils through most colors, but are primarily supported in Blue and Red. Similarly, the gameplans are diversely arrayed as well. Jam Talismen until Batterskull and Wurmcoil Engine drop? Check. Cracking infinite baubles and spellbombs with Emery and Goblin Engineer? Check. Splash black to drain some poor nerd for a billion with Tezzeret, Agent of Bolas? That's a house special.
Sometimes you wanna cast powerful blue spells without dragging the game out 37 turns. For those days, there's tempo. Wring every bit of value out of your deck by playing disruptive, mana efficient spells such as Vendilion Clique and Memory Lapse to put opponents on the back foot and keep them there until your army of 3/1's kill them. Splash black for infinite disruption, white for aggressive creatures, red for reach, or green for bulky flash creatures.
Build Arounds:One of life's greatest struggles is delayed gratification. Suffer a bit now so that you may enjoy ever greater pleasures later. That's a bit what it's like trying to draft a Pod deck. During the draft process, you have to keep a fairly meticulous eye on your curve, lest you slam a Birthing Pod onto the table with no one way to chain up for value. If you get it right, however...well, there's a reason that a legion of diehard nerds still pine over the bygone days of Pod decks in Modern. Playing a good Pod deck is a uniquely satisfying experience. Plus, the new Fiend Artisan not only adds another redundant effect, but also helps further bridge the gap between this build around and the next one.
Survival of the Fittest gave the world a Legacy metagame in which every conceivable color combination and pace of play could be accommodated...as long as you ran Survival. The amount of value and control this card gives you is so high that an immeasurably worse version of Survival, Fauna Shaman, is still a good card. And if Survival is chocolate, than Recurring Nightmare is peanut butter. Pitch Grave Titan with Survival to tutor up Ravenous Chupacabra. Kill something with the Chupathingy so you can sacrifice said Chupathingy to get back Grave Titan with Recurring Nightmare. Even before you start repeating the loop, I think you've generated a literally 4000-for-1 worth of value and fun.
Do you like playing good value creatures? Wanna do it again? This is less a build around than the rest. In fact, to my mind, it's the exact opposite of a build around. It's more a very powerful payoff for doing something already powerful. You don't need to build around Soulherder to be good. Just draft a GW value deck full of Eternal Witnesss, Jadelight Rangers, and Skyclave Apparitions and then splash blue for a one card value engine. Or play a UG tempo deck and splash white for Ephemerate and Restoration Angel. Welcome, to the Circus of Value!
Like aggressively putting opponents' life total to zero, but tired of running out of gas? Recycle your crappy old Goblin Guides with Blood Artist! Clog up the board with Lingering Souls and Pia and Kiran Nalaar, then jam a Zulaport Cutthroat and suicide everyone into the trenches. Explode your opponents brain after they spend 30 minutes doing combat math on how to best survive by smashing a Goblin Bombardment onto the table on your second main phase. Rip someone's heart out inch-by-inch by looping a single Dread Wanderer through said Bombardment after your opponent hopes they've stabilized.
Hearthstone has made a lucrative "card" game out of cutting the mana system out of Magic, so the only logical thing for Magic cubes to do is to steer into the skid and make an entire archetype built around lands! Golos, Tireless Pilgrim can grab Field of the Dead AKA The Inevitability Engine That Broke Multiple Constructed Formats. Fetchlands are already some of the most powerful cards in Magic, so let's make them stronger, huh? Wanna turn a basic forest into Lair of the Hydra or Raging Ravine? Elvish Reclaimer does too. Anyone who thinks drafting lands is the most boring part of Cube needs to jam The Gitrog Monster and strap in.
There are a few build around cards or archetypes that are on my radar, but, for one reason or another, are not currently in the cube.
Cards Intentionally Excluded
Returning to the cube after a long hiatus.
Cleaning up some of the cutesy low-end power outliers in favor of stronger and/or cheaper effects.
I'm also doubling down on a leaner identity for green. No more playing around with Craterhoof and Prime Time. Cheap dorks, big, beefy midrange threats, and toolbox-y selection.
I'm also bringing in a couple Universe Beyond cards. I don't love the concept and some of them are too out there for me to ever really dig, but I'm trying some out and seeing if they cause me any irrational angst.
Hey, Inwas checking out your cube and I like a lot of what is happening. I have a similar cube (maybe a bit more combo oriented), and was wondering how Recurring Nightmare plays out for you?
I am seriously considering adding it, but am afraid of it taking over games and being super repetitive.
What is your experience like with it?